Clear Situation, Great Resolve, Correct Method

I. Source

The nine characters “Clear Situation, Great Resolve, Correct Method” (情况明、决心大、方法对) do not appear in any single article of the Selected Works. Instead, they were spoken by Mao Zedong at a Central Work Conference in January 1961.

Context:

  • Time: January 1961
  • Occasion: Central Work Conference (also known as the preparatory meeting for the “Seven Thousand Cadres Conference”)
  • Background: During the period of severe national economic difficulties caused by the consequences of the “Great Leap Forward.”
  • Original Quote:

    “In our future work, we must achieve three things: clear situation, great resolve, and correct method.”

This statement was later included in:

  • Collected Writings of Mao Zedong, Volume 8
  • Manuscripts of Mao Zedong Since the Founding of the PRC, Volume 9

However, although these nine characters were explicitly formulated in 1961, this system of thought permeates the entirety of the Selected Works.


II. Core Articles in the Selected Works Reflecting This Thought

While Clear Situation, Great Resolve, Correct Method appeared late as a complete phrase, its intellectual roots can be traced back to several classic articles in the Selected Works:

1. The Intellectual Source of [Clear Situation]

The Most Core Article: Oppose Book Worship (May 1930)

Original Title: Investigation Work

Core Golden Quotes:

“No investigation, no right to speak.” “You can’t solve that problem? Well, get down and investigate the present facts and its past history! When you have investigated the problem thoroughly, you will know how to solve it.”

Why It Matters: This article directly answers how to achieve a “Clear Situation”—through investigation and research. Research and investigation must be done with a specific purpose and directed toward specific problems.

In this text, Mao fiercely criticized dogmatists (“Book Worshipers”) who did not understand China’s actual reality and could only recite Marxist-Leninist classics. He proposed:

  • Investigation is the foundation of all work.
  • “The victory of the Chinese revolutionary struggle depends on the Chinese comrades’ understanding of Chinese conditions.”

The Second Most Important: On Practice (July 1937)

Subtitle: On the Relation Between Knowledge and Practice, Between Knowing and Doing

Core Thought:

“Practice, knowledge, again practice, and again knowledge. This form repeats itself in endless cycles, and with each cycle the content of practice and knowledge rises to a higher level.”

Why It Matters: This article discusses the epistemological basis of “Clear Situation” from a philosophical height:

  • Knowledge comes from practice (not from sitting in a room thinking).
  • Knowledge must be returned to practice for verification (no armchair strategies).
  • It requires repeated cycles (the situation is dynamic, so investigation must be continuous).

Correspondence to the “Nine-Character Mantra”:

  • Clear Situation = Obtaining correct knowledge through practice.
  • Correct Method = Using correct knowledge to guide practice.

The Third Most Important: On Contradiction (August 1937)

Core Thought:

“In studying a problem, we must shun subjectivity, one-sidedness and superficiality.” “Qualitatively different contradictions can only be resolved by qualitatively different methods.”

Why It Matters: This article teaches you “how to see the situation clearly”:

  • Distinguish between the principal contradiction and secondary contradictions.
  • Distinguish between the principal aspect and the secondary aspect of a contradiction.
  • Analyze concrete problems concretely (no “one size fits all”).

The text cites “Song Jiang Attacking the Zhu Family Manor”:

“In the novel Water Margin, Song Jiang thrice attacked the Zhu Family Manor. Twice he was defeated because he was ignorant of the local conditions and used the wrong method. Later he changed his method; first he investigated the situation, and he familiarized himself with the maze of roads, then he broke up the alliance between the Li, Hu and Zhu Villages and sent his men in disguise into the enemy camp as a Trojan horse. And on the third occasion he won.”

On Contradiction explicitly states: “Ignorant of local conditions, used the wrong method” (Situation unclear, method incorrect)!


2. The Intellectual Source of [Great Resolve]

The Most Core Article: On Protracted War (May 1938)

Background: In the early stages of the War of Resistance Against Japanese Aggression, two erroneous trends of thought existed domestically: “Theory of National Subjugation” and “Theory of Quick Victory.”

Core Thought: Through a deep analysis of the fundamental characteristics of both China and Japan, Mao concluded:

  • Japan will fail.
  • China will win.
  • But it requires a protracted war (Three stages: strategic defensive, strategic stalemate, strategic counter-offensive).

Why This Is “Great Resolve”: Because in the most difficult moment (when the Japanese army had occupied half of China), Mao used a profound analysis of the “situation” to provide a verdict of “inevitable victory,” giving the whole nation the confidence to persist.

Correspondence to the “Nine-Character Mantra”:

“The clearer the situation, the greater the resolve.”

Mao dared to make the conclusion of “inevitable victory in a protracted war” (Great Resolve) precisely because he had thoroughly analyzed the conditions of both sides (Clear Situation).


The Second Most Important: The Foolish Old Man Who Removed the Mountains (June 1945)

Background: Closing speech at the Seventh National Congress.

Core Thought:

“Two big mountains lie like a dead weight on the Chinese people. One is imperialism, the other is feudalism. The Chinese Communist Party has long made up its mind to dig them up. We must persevere and work unceasingly, and we, too, will touch God’s heart. This God is none other than the masses of the Chinese people.”

Why This Is “Great Resolve”: Although brief, this speech embodies a determination of “knowing there are tigers on the mountain, yet insisting on going to the mountain”—but this determination is not blind; it is based on a profound understanding of the power of the “masses” (Clear Situation).


3. The Intellectual Source of [Correct Method]

The Most Core Article: Problems of Strategy in China’s Revolutionary War (December 1936)

Core Thought:

“The laws of war—this is a problem that anyone directing a war must study and solve.” “The laws of revolutionary war in China—this is a problem that anyone directing China’s revolutionary war must study and solve.”

Why It Matters: This article systematically discusses “where methods come from”:

  • Not by copying Soviet experience (Dogmatism).
  • Not by copying ancient Chinese military strategy (Revivalism).
  • But by summarizing them from the “specific characteristics of China’s revolutionary war.”

Proposed Famous Tactical Principles:

  • “The 16-Character Formula”: The enemy advances, we retreat; the enemy camps, we harass; the enemy tires, we attack; the enemy retreats, we pursue.
  • “Lure the enemy in deep.”
  • “Concentrate superior forces to destroy the enemy forces one by one.”

Correspondence to the “Nine-Character Mantra”: These methods were not brainstormed out of thin air; they were summarized from practice based on the recognition of the basic situation: “the enemy is strong, and we are weak.”


The Second Most Important: On the Ten Major Relationships (April 1956)

Core Thought:

“Recently the Soviet Union has exposed some defects and errors in their process of building socialism. Do you want to follow the detours they have taken? It was by drawing lessons from their experience that we were able to avoid certain detours in the past, and there is all the more reason for us to do so now.”

Why It Matters: This speech embodies the core principle of “Correct Method”:

  • Do not copy others’ experiences blindly (even “Big Brother” Soviet Union).
  • Start from China’s actual situation.
  • “Take the Soviet Union as a warning” and walk our own path.

III. Summary of the Intellectual Thread

Although the nine characters “Clear Situation, Great Resolve, Correct Method” were only spoken in 1961, this system of thought is consistent throughout the Selected Works:

Nine-Character Mantra Corresponding Philosophy Core Articles Key Golden Quote
Clear Situation Epistemology On Practice, On Contradiction, Oppose Book Worship “No investigation, no right to speak.”
Great Resolve Belief System / Willpower On Protracted War, The Foolish Old Man Who Removed the Mountains “The clearer the situation, the greater the resolve.”
Correct Method Methodology Problems of Strategy in China’s Revolutionary War, On the Ten Major Relationships “Analyze concrete problems concretely.”

IV. Why Were These Nine Characters Only Proposed in 1961?

Because by 1961, Mao Zedong needed to summarize the lessons of the “Great Leap Forward.”

The errors of the Great Leap Forward were precisely a violation of these nine characters:

  • Situation Unclear: Lack of deep investigation into China’s productivity levels and resource conditions; blindly proposing to “surpass the UK and catch up with the USA.”
  • Resolve Misplaced: The determination was great, but it was built on an incorrect judgment of the situation (overestimating human subjective initiative).
  • Method Incorrect: Using methods that violated objective laws, such as “backyard steel furnaces” and claiming “yields of ten thousand jin per mu.”

Therefore, this speech in 1961 was essentially a painful self-criticism:

“We must not make such mistakes again in the future. We must achieve: Clear situation, great resolve, correct method.”